There are many ways to train your dogs or correct any of their undesirable behavior. Using shock collars is considered to be one of the effective ways for these purposes. However, a shock collar also called an e-collar or electric collar is also one of the most controversial tools to control dogs’ behavior.
The fact that it gives an electric shock to the pets, puts off many of the dog owners or animal lovers. Their concern is justifiable if the tool is used by an untrained person.
But if used by a skilled trainer, the same tool can yield wonderful results without hurting the pets. In this article, we will discuss many different aspects of shock collars-including their working, benefits, disadvantages, and factors to consider when buying the best shock collar.
A quick list of checked collars:
- Dog Training Collar
- Slopehill Dog Training Collar
- PATPET Dog Training Collar
- PATPET 2 In 1 Dog Training Collar
- Bousnic Dog Shock Collar for 2 Dogs
- SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Trainers
- PATPET Dog Training Collar
1. Dog Training Collar – Rechargeable Dog Shock Collar
The DOG CARE dog training collar is one of the best dog training collars. It has three training modes i.e. Beep, Vibration, and Shock. The dog collar operates through a remote. Dog Training Collar is used during training sessions of the dog. Beep and Vibration modes of the collar are very useful during basic training like teaching obedience etc.
The remote range is very long so that you can use the Dog Training Collar indoor as well as for outdoor hiking. Outdoor training sessions include catch the ball, fetch something, and so on. This collar is rainproof so your dog can easily do outdoor activities with this. At the time of swimming, you can remotely switch off the shock collar. This shock collar is made of ABS material which is very strong and durable.
The shock training collar can be easily charged using any USB charger. You can also charge it with the power bank. It shows the battery level for both the collar and the remote.
Overall, the Dog Training Collar is one of the best electric dog collars for your dog to teach good behavior. It is very lightweight and easy to handle, requiring no maintenance.
- Long-range remote control
- Excellent collar for training
- Shows battery level
- Sometime collar cause sores on the dog neck
- Vibration mode is not very effective
Slopehill dog training collar is one of the best bark collars. It is specially designed with a very low voltage to avoid any harm to the dog. It has various levels of Beep, Vibration, and Static Stimulation mode. You can choose any of the modes according to your need. Conductive silicon points provide complete safety to your dog during training sessions.
It has a very high-quality rechargeable battery so you do not need to worry about charging again and again. The battery of the remote runs for at least 45 days and the receiver’s battery last up to 15 days.
The most appealing feature of the Slopehill training collar is that a single remote can provide support to 3 dog training collars. Using a single click you can switch the channels. The collar has a built-in light and reflective strap. This helps to find your dog easily during the night time. The range of remote is very high so you can easily train your dog indoors as well as outdoors.
It comes with a USB charging cable so you can charge the remote and receiver both at the same time.
- Very high-quality collar
- Three training modes
- Conductive silicone points
- Built-in light
- Reflective strap
- Shock feature is not perfect
3. PATPET Dog Training Collar with Remote
PATPET Dog Training Collar is one of the best dog bark collars on the list. It has 16 levels of static shock and 8 levels of Beep and Vibration modes. The remote works in the range of up to 1000 ft so the collar can be used for in-house as well as out of the house training. It has anti-jamming technology that provides a strong and stable signal without any disturbances.
The design of the PATPET training collar is very simple and easy to wear. The pet owner feels very comfortable during operations. It has a very powerful Lithium-ion battery. The receiver battery lasts up to 10-11 days and the remote battery comfortably works up to 65-70 days.
The collar has conductive silicon prongs that provide maximum safety to the dog during training. The collar is made from IPX7 waterproof so the dog feels comfortable during water activities. IPX7 waterproof provides submerging into the water for at least half an hour comfortably, but submerging should not be deeper than a meter.
Overall, the PATPET Dog Training Collar works perfectly well and gives your dog complete comfort during training sessions. The long remote range helps you to provide training both indoor and outdoor.
- 16 levels of shock and 8 levels of beep & vibration mode
- Anti-jamming technology
- 65-70 days battery backup of remote
- IPX7 waterproof
- Conductive silicone prongs to provide full safety
- Vibration mode is not effective
- Collar switches off by itself
4. Bousnic Shock Collar for Dogs
The Bousnic Shock Collar for Dogs is the best bark collar for small dogs in the market. Its wireless receiver operates by a remote that works up to very long distances without any disturbance. This collar helps your dog to understand good behavior and bad behavior by sensing its different levels of different modes.
You can completely control your dog in the house and public places by using these modes. After getting a perfect stimulating level for your dog you can lock it as the best level. You can increase or decrease this locked level as per the need.
It comes in different shapes & sizes for different breeds. Its adjustable beep and static shock mode make it very simple to operate as they can adjust with your dog’s behavior. It has an IPX7 waterproof receiver and an IPX5 waterproof remote that helps to maintain the longevity of the product. The battery life of this product is very long.
Overall, the Bousnic Shock Collar for Dogs is one of the best e collars for dogs for those who want to train their dogs softly and safely.
- IPX7 waterproof receiver & IPX5 waterproof remote
- Soft & Smooth collar
- Long-range of remote
- Long battery life
- Beep mode miscommunicates sometimes
5. Bousnic Dog Shock Collar for 2 Dogs
Bousnic Dog Shock Collar is one of the best anti bark collars. It is used to train the dog safely without any pain. This Shock collar has 2 adjusting levels of beep, vibration, and static shock modes. These modes help to teach the basic obedience command and inculcate good behavior in your dog.
It has a remote range of up to 1000ft. So, you can train your dog not only inside the house but also outdoors. You can use different modes with the help of a remote and lock the best mode for your dog. The remote is covered with silicon and has an attractive LED screen. The design of the remote is very sleek. It has a security keypad lock to avoid any misoperation.
Bousnic Dog Shock Collar has a soft conductive silicon cover that gives full protection to the dog and avoids any irritation. It has a specially designed spring sheet that supports shock mode to work efficiently on the dog having long and thick hair.
- Provide full protection
- Conductive silicon cover avoid any irritation
- Spring sheet to support shock mode
- Quality material
- No clip on the remote
6. SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Trainers
SportDOG Brand 425X is one of the lightest collars for in-field training dogs. This remotely operated training collar helps you to focus on the training of the dog. SportDOG is perfect for outdoor training or hunting. It ranges up to 500 yards and a single remote can work on 3 collars at the same time.
It has 21 levels of static stimulation. You can choose any of the modes as per your choice. You can also use the level of stimulation as per your dog’s need. It uses Dry Tek Technology that makes the collar waterproof and can be submerged for up to 25 feet into the water.
The remote and receiver have Lithium-ion high-quality rechargeable batteries that quickly charge within 2 hrs or less. It also has a low battery indicator.
Overall, the SportDOG 425X training collar is the perfect choice to train the dog for hunting or any other sports activity. The shock is completely harmless and trains your dog safely
- Dry Tek Technology
- High-quality lithium-ion battery
- Quickly recharge
- Perfect for the dog for hunting training
- 1-year warranty
- Not suitable for small and soft dogs
The PATPET Dog Training Collar perfectly trains and improves the behavior of your dog. It has conductive silicon points that provide full safety to your dog. The collar has a nylon strap that fits perfectly on the neck of your dog thus avoiding the biting of the straps by the dog.
The remote control can be easily carried with a hand strap. You can also keep it in your pocket when not in use. Always remember to switch it off when not in use to avoid any misoperations. Through this remote, you can use different modes of the collar and communicate with your dog very effectively.
The remote has a large LED screen that displays everything very clearly. You can select any of the levels you want. It uses AAA batteries that are more powerful and harmless in comparison with any other rechargeable batteries. The unit comes with two extra-long contact points that help to contact the dog having long and thick hair.
- Additional Extra-long contact point
- Large LED display screen
- Powerful AAA batteries
- Nylon Strap
- Vibration mode not very effective
What are the different uses of Shock Collars?
Shock collars are used for multiple purposes. Some of them include,
To Control Excessive Barking
These collars are designed specially to control the barking of dogs by triggering an electrical impulse through their vocal cord movement. Some of these collars do not necessarily require the presence of the owner near the pet.
Some dogs show undesirable behavior like unnecessary aggression, jumping on people, running behind vehicles, and so on. Shock collars can be used as a deterrent for such behaviors. They can also be used to train pets to learn good behavior and follow instructions.
As a Perimeter Tool
You can use e-collars to prevent your pet from leaving a specified area for their safety. However, you need special collars to limit your dog movements within their yard and normal shock collars used for controlling barking may not be effective for the purpose.
For Hunting Training
The functionality of collars as a hunting tool is similar to the shock collars used for controlling the behavior of the pet. However, you may like to have some more features like a bigger range or waterproof collar, etc. when you want to use a shock collar to train the dog for hunting.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Shock Collars
Every gadget has some positive aspects associated with it and also have some flip sides that may be disadvantageous to its users. Shock collars also offer many advantages and at the same time pose unique challenges when used on your pet to control their behavior. The following are some of the pros and cons of using a shock collar:
Makes Pets Instantly Aware About Their Bad Behavior
It is one of the most effective ways to communicate instantly to your pet about its undesirable or bad behavior. For instance, if your pet is jumping on someone, you may start shouting at your pet to stop it. But it may be too late before the dog understands that you are not happy with its behavior. A shock collar, in such situations, can instantly stop the dog’s activity and safeguard others from potential harm, and also makes the dog realize the behavior it is not supposed to repeat.
Faster Training Results
Though there is no substitute for professional training, many canine trainers have observed that using shock collars along with training help in quicker learning compared to other supporting tools.
For normal training, a professional trainer can be very expensive. A shock collar can serve the purpose of correcting undesirable behavior at a very affordable rate. Moreover, buying a shock collar is only a one-time investment. This avoids the need to pay recurring training fees to the professional.
Since time immemorial there has been an unending debate on the most effective method of training. One school of thought believes that only positive methods like rewarding good behavior should be used for training- both humans and animals. While there is another viewpoint that considers using punishment as a more effective way of teaching. Those who only believe in positive reinforcement completely disagree with the use of shock collars to train canines.
In all the indicative training methods, it is important for the trainee dog to correctly interpret the reason for receiving the signals. In case the canine misinterprets the reason for receiving the shock through a shock collar, it may make the pet fearful and harm the learning process irreparably.
At times it is too subtle for your pet to correctly associate the shock with the behavior to be corrected and the pet may consider a closely related habit to be bad and stop repeating it. This may cause more harm than good.
Harmful for Your Bonding with the Pet
Again, as mentioned earlier, the pet needs to associate the shock with its undesirable behavior. In case the canine, rather than linking the stimuli with its behavior, links it with you causing the unpleasant sensation, it may lead to a very bad relationship between you and your pet. In certain situations, the pet may develop a feeling of deep fear towards you and may not establish the lovable relationship so essential for living together.
Factors to Consider When Buying a Shock Collar
After going through the reviews of the top 7 best shock collars, you would have shortlisted a few of them suitable for your purpose. We will now recommend you to go through the detailed buyers guide to select the best one that fulfills your requirements.
To have adjustable shock levels is one of the most important factors that you must consider while shopping for a shock collar. This feature helps in adjusting the shock level according to the size, nature, and strength of your dog.
An obstinate dog may need a higher shock level compared to a gentle breed. Similarly, a small dog may need a less intense shock to realize it’s bad behavior compared to a strong canine. Shock level higher than required may instill a feeling of fear in the dog while too little a shock may not be effective to make the dog realize its bad behavior.
If you are planning to buy the shock collar to be used by home-trainers, collar range is not a very important factor to be considered. However, for the dogs being trained for hunting, it is one of the major criteria of selection.
So, depending on the usage type you can select the shock collar with a range between 200 yards to 3520 yards and even more. For the at-home training purpose, you can select short-range collars ranging from 200 yards to half a mile.
You can choose the medium-range collars ranging between half a mile to one mile for yard training and off-leash movement for the working dogs. The range over a mile up to 2 miles or more is appropriate for the hunting training.
The range of the collar gets affected by the changing weather conditions and the line of sight between the signal transmitter and the collar. Besides, it will also get impacted by the terrain you are using the collar. For hunting purposes, it may not be possible to have a line of sight, so buy a stronger collar than required for such purposes.
Many shock collars include multiple sizes of the probe. You must select the probe size according to the coat of the dog. Short collar probes are suitable for dogs with short and thin coats while the bigger probes work effectively for dogs having long and thick coats.
Type of Transmitter Controls
Different collar manufacturers provide different types of transmitter controls. Each type offers its advantages in controlling the transmission during training. You can select according to your usage.
The basic feature of a rheostat or free spinning dials is their smooth movement. You can easily set them to the desired value by moving the dial knob back and forth. However, it is difficult to set the exact levels in the free-spinning types of dials as they do not have any tension between different values. Moreover, many of these dials will require you to use both your hands which can be troublesome in certain conditions.
The button system is also a very common system to change the shock levels of a dog collar. It is usually connected with an LCD screen to indicate the present shock level. Many dog owners like these units owing to their user-friendly features. However, the button system with an LCD screen will require you to look at the screen to know the shock level. This may not be quite practical for many dog trainers.
Click-dials have the biggest advantage of fixing the shock level at an exact value. You can simply turn the dial to click at the desired level. The convenience of using these dials make them highly popular among many dog trainers.
While selecting any of the dial systems, make sure that they are easy to operate and suitable for the size of your hand. In case you wear hand gloves while using these dials, get the dial system that has bigger buttons or knobs making it easy to set different levels.
Size of the Transmitter
Different transmitters manufacturers offer different sizes and shapes. Most users like to have a compact and small transmitter unit. They are handy, easy to use, and can be kept in a small space. However, people with large hands may find it difficult to operate small units. They prefer having a bulky unit which also allows them to use the unit with gloves, as well.
Some shock collars directly apply shock to the collar while others offer an alert in the form of a beep sound or vibration before triggering the shock. This is a more compassionate method that allows the dog to improve its behavior without requiring to administer the shock. The dog becomes alert hearing the sound of the beep or feeling vibrations and stops doing the undesirable activity instantly.
This feature is particularly adored by the owners who do not want to use negative reinforcement or use it as their last resort. They create an association of shock with the alert and the bad behavior during the first few incidences only. Later the dog responds desirably with the beep or vibration itself.
In some cases, the trainers do not need to even give static shock as some dogs respond to the alert from the very beginning of the session.
Between the beep/tone and vibration, many owners prefer vibration over the tone mode. It is for the reason that the tone released by the unit can be similar to the tone of some other equipment in your home or the training area.
For instance, it may resemble the beep of a microwave, the cell phone, or any other gadgets giving alarms. The dog, in such situations, may get confused and may either overreact or respond inappropriately to the real alert tone.
Water-resistant or Waterproof
Being an electronic gadget, it is important to protect the shock collar from water, particularly during the rains. The entry of water may lead to malfunction of the unit or its complete damage. So, the unit you buy should at least be water-resistant. If you are training your dog in an area that is prone to rains or training hunting dogs, you must opt for the waterproof model of the shock collars.
Depending on the usage type you can select shock collars with the required battery power. For the at-home training, you may opt for a battery with low power while for the hunting training you should prefer a powerful battery.
Buying a suitable dog shock collar is not easy. However, with the right information about the best shock collars, it becomes a cakewalk to select the best one for your purpose. We hope that the reviews and other important information given in the article were helpful for you in selecting the best shock collar for your pet.